FFT school belonging analysis featured in TES

FFT school belonging analysis featured in TES

By FFT

FFT Education Datalab’s analysis of school belonging has been covered by TES. The analysis finds that initiatives focused solely on improving pupils’ sense of belonging are unlikely to lead to large improvements in attainment.

The analysis, written by John Jerrim, professor of education and social statistics at UCL Institute of Education, looked at how Year 9 pupils’ sense of belonging relates to their later GCSE results. It also drew on international data from PISA, TIMSS and PIRLS.

At first glance there appears to be a meaningful link as pupils with a stronger sense of belonging achieved around half a grade higher in GCSE maths. However, once demographics, the school attended, key stage 2 results and previous absence and exclusions are considered, this difference falls to an improvement of around one-sixth of a GCSE grade.

The analysis also notes that surveys that measure school belonging can be varied – measuring distinct things, from enjoyment of school and feeling safe to relationships with teachers and peers. This is important because without clarity on what is being measured, data on belonging may not be that relevant.

As both the TES piece and the Datalab blog note, this does not mean belonging is not important. Feeling accepted and supported may matter for pupils’ wellbeing, attendance and experience of school, which are worthwhile outcomes. Monitoring belonging can still be useful for schools, provided it is linked to specific, tangible actions rather than carried out purely to drive up attainment.

This will be especially relevant as schools prepare for the Schools White Paper’s expectation that all schools measure pupils’ sense of belonging and engagement from 2029.

You can read the TES coverage here: https://www.tes.com/magazine/news/general/school-belonging-schemes-unlikely-lead-big-rises-attainment

And you can read the two blog posts via Datalab here: https://ffteducationdatalab.org.uk/blog/

Read more like this on our News and Resources page.